Section 106 and social value: valuable is not always additional

Omar Hadjel MCIM | Hadom Consulting

When a new housing development goes ahead, it can put pressure on local services and create a need for supporting infrastructure. In England, a Section 106 agreement lets the council secure legally binding commitments needed to make a development acceptable. Depending on the site, that might mean providing affordable homes or helping to pay for extra school places.

Take a developer whose agreement requires 20 affordable homes. If it delivers all 20, those homes can make a real difference to the people who live in them. The agreement gives us a starting point for reporting that contribution. We can show what the developer was required to provide, what it actually delivered and what changed for the people it was meant to benefit. Each tells us something different about the development’s social value.

That distinction came into focus in my conversation with Dr Malachy Buck of London South Bank University, in connection with an ongoing research project, funded by the Royal Town Planning Institute. The project examines how planning obligations are used, valued and reported to deliver social value.

My argument is simple: before calculating social value, clarify the claim.

Three different questions

We need to distinguish what planning secures, what communities experience and what a developer delivers beyond the applicable requirements. These are different questions, not three totals to add together.

In England, Section 106 is a planning mechanism, not a procurement requirement. Obligations relied upon in granting permission must be necessary for planning acceptability, directly related to the development, and fairly and reasonably related in scale and kind. Calling something “social value” does not bypass those tests.

I would distinguish the compliance baseline—what was required—from the evaluation counterfactual: what would probably have happened otherwise. Exceeding a target does not automatically establish additional impact.

Mitigation is not automatically a net gain

Consider a development that increases demand for school places and funds extra capacity. That contribution matters. But counting the new places while ignoring the additional demand risks presenting mitigation as a net improvement.

Equally, we should not assume mitigation brings every impact precisely back to zero. We need evidence of who benefits, who bears costs and what pressures remain.

Better evidence, not just bigger numbers

Suppose ten apprenticeship starts are required and twelve are delivered. That establishes two starts above target—not twelve additional, sustained employment outcomes. Completion, progression and what would probably have happened anyway still need examination.

My practical proposal is an obligation-to-outcome record: connect each commitment to its beneficiaries, delivery status, evidence and accountable owner. Identify other contributors, so shared outcomes are not counted repeatedly.

I would use monetary valuation alongside the underlying evidence, with assumptions, uncertainty and potential overlaps disclosed. A monetary proxy cannot establish causation.

Communities should help determine which outcomes matter, not simply receive the finished report. Completing a facility does not establish whether people can access it or whether it meets their needs.

For planners, shared definitions and worked examples may therefore be more useful than another calculator. Standardise how claims are substantiated, without standardising away local needs.

Planning’s contribution deserves recognition. Credibility comes from explaining what changed, for whom and why—not from producing the largest number.

These are my reflections, not findings or recommendations of the research.

Omar Hadjel MCIM - Bids & Proposals Consultant

Omar Hadjel MCIM is a public sector procurement specialist, bid support consultant, and GRI-certified sustainability professional, and the founder of Hadom Consulting Ltd.

He helps organisations win public contracts and strengthen their social value and sustainability propositions through practical, evaluator-friendly approaches that align policy intent with delivery reality. Omar works across public procurement, social value, ESG reporting, and sustainability strategy, supporting local authorities, NHS suppliers, housing providers, VCSEs, and SMEs.

https://www.linkedin.com/in/omarhadjel/
Previous
Previous

The framework was reviewed. What should you check again at call-off?

Next
Next

Your bid team is already using AI. Is anyone managing how?